Texas Sunset Commission States the Obvious: TWIA Is Financially Unsustainable


The Texas Windstorm Insurance coverage Affiliation (TWIA), the state-created residual market that gives windstorm insurance coverage insurance policies in 14 designated coastal counties, suffers from “basic flaws” within the company’s design, in accordance with a scathing report by the Texas Sundown Fee.

In Texas, many state businesses are topic to periodic “sundown” evaluation and should be periodically renewed by the Legislature. To help on this course of, the Sundown Fee opinions every company’s goal and efficiency, and might make suggestions for adjustments and updates to its governing statutes.

It’s uncommon for an company to not be renewed in any respect, however the want for legislative reaffirmation creates a possibility to make reforms that in any other case may get misplaced within the bustle of the legislative schedule. And whereas TWIA isn’t required to undergo the complete sundown course of, the fee can evaluation its operations, because it did earlier this month in a report that detailed affiliation’s dire monetary state.

The report’s essential bullet factors received’t be information to anybody who has been paying consideration. TWIA was initially created to function an “insurer of final resort,” to supply windstorm insurance coverage to those that can’t discover it on the open market. To realize this purpose, TWIA gives insurance policies at charges considerably decrease in mixture than what could be wanted to pay possible most losses. Consequently, TWIA has confronted persistent monetary difficulties. Regardless of some enhancements to its monetary place throughout a lull in storm exercise following 2008’s Hurricane Ike, final yr’s Hurricane Harvey as soon as once more underlined the company’s fiscally unsound place.

The report lists quite a lot of legislative adjustments that might make TWIA operate higher, together with a extra streamlined “takeout” course of for personal insurers, like these which have been executed efficiently in states like Florida and Louisiana. However its core conclusion is that the Legislature faces a selection between whether or not to “[c]ontinue TWIA as an insurer of final resort or proceed TWIA as an insurance coverage firm reliant totally on premium funding.”

On one degree it’s laborious to argue with this. There are, nevertheless, some methods to separate the distinction. The Legislature may, for instance, limit eligibility for TWIA to properties valued at lower than $500,000 or require properties to fulfill sure constructing code necessities to mitigate the potential for storm harm in the event that they wish to proceed to take pleasure in TWIA protection. The affiliation additionally may go a good distance towards eradicating incentives to develop in dangerous areas by making new development within the coastal zone ineligible for TWIA protection.

TWIA additionally has had some luck utilizing reinsurance as a risk-management technique. Altogether, TWIA positioned $2.6 billion of reinsurance in 2018, up 24 p.c from final yr. Again in April, TWIA got here to market with a proposed $300 million disaster bond – the fourth in its Alamo Re Ltd. collection – and after a couple of weeks of procuring round had upped the provide to $400 million, at a coupon that was 13 p.c less expensive than initially projected. Market circumstances nonetheless appear favorable for TWIA to leverage the worldwide reinsurance market to put off much more of its danger.

In any occasion, the Sundown Fee’s report underscores that TWIA’s issues aren’t going away. Whether or not the Legislature decides to fix TWIA or to finish it, it should act quickly, earlier than the subsequent storm hits.

Need to keep updated?

Get the newest insurance coverage information
despatched straight to your inbox.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here